عجفت الغور

Mamdani - Trans-African Slaveries Thinking Historically

Tags: problems and methods

  • Talks about how slavery cannot be defined solely as chattel slavery
  • Argues against the notion put out by Orlando Patterson and Bruce Hall
  • Islamic forms of slavery were actually a part of the slave market that eventually turned into chattel slavery
  • Chattel slavery and free people were two sides of the same coin, examples where the people were the most free (like Athens) also had the most chattel slavery
  • Shift of greeks and romans from half free people to reliance on chattel slaves from outside was the emergence of the idea of freedom
  • Argues that Patterson, in his attempt to find a coherent definition of slavery, overlooked many differences
    • In Islam, Mamaluks
    • In Ethopia, various other groups
  • Early data about #s of slaves were largely anecdotal and basically wild guesses
  • Zanj rebellion in Iraq, lead by Ali
    • Large, spartacus like revolt from Southern iraq of free people and poors
    • Lasted over 15 years
  • Race based slavery was a western import, largely allowing for racialized taxonomies with colonialization
    • previously one could “become” an arab, just as you could convert to islam
  • Haterin in northern Morocco
  • Universal definitions of slavery is a fool’s errand, too difficult to actually conceptualize
  • Segregation produces a clear divide between slave and non-slave, while the dominant discourse on slavery has been defined as the meeting point of abolitionist and Orientialist

Links to this note