عجفت الغور

Hobbes - Introduction to Religious Language

Chapter 1

  • Work on religious language started in the 1980s after Jean Pierre van Noppen
    • explored the question of “where is god”
  • Muslim sermons (Esimaje, 2014) or (Malmstrom, 2016) and Prayers (Shoaps 2002)
  • Main questions to ask
    • what counts as religious language?
    • who uses it?
    • where can it be found?
    • what are its distinctive features?
    • what purposes does it serve?

Chapter 2 - What is Religion? What is Religious Language?

  • closed vs open definitions of religion
  • closed - rooted in distinction between the secular and the sacred
    • about limits, around how you define this wrt to spirit or faith, especially with something immaterial or supernatural or otherwise trasncendent entity.
    • closed religion sees religion as the same as religious institutions, and their adherents, beliefs, rituals, traditions, and practices
    • what about religious language within secular spaces? AA for example, speaks of a higher power
  • open definitions of religion
    • durkheim’ian sense of religion as sacred
    • resolves to an open sense of what religion is and could be (is metaphysics a religion? is AA a religion?), but even this involves drawing boundaries
      • but religion as a connelly “political settlement” proves the impossibility of discussing what religion is
  • studies around ideaology and collective identity as a response to linguistics
    • what is an ideology? from van Dijk
      • ideologies are a set of beliefs
      • they are axiomatic
      • they are socially shared
      • they are gradually acquired
    • difference between ideology and religion? ideology is typically resistance against mainstream societal norms
  • role of the “sacred” in religion
    • is classical arabic sacred?
    • following edward baily people tend to use the term ‘implict religion’
    • thinking about what religion does, religious language is space-creating